Nobody's Perfect. Everybody's Flawless

Robert De Niro in drag? Now that would be a sight to behold, although not one I actually want to consider. Thankfully, this isn't the case, we'll make do with Phillip Seymour Hoffman instead, but in direct confrontation with our Bobby. Not the kind of confrontation you might be thinking of though, this is more from the school of cantankerous old git versus flamboyant transsexual, which is an intriguing start.

De Niro plays Walt, a grumpy and full on conservative retired security guard. When Walt suffers a stroke that leaves him with partial paralysis, he is reluctantly coddled into agreeing to let Rusty (Hoffman), the drag queen who lives above him, teach him how to sing as a means of recovery. Think a bit like As Good As It Gets but not cod (how HOW did it win Oscars???)

In the surprise of the year, Joel Schumacher (on a double whammy of excrement following 'Batman and Robin' and '8mm'…shiver) delivers a small-scale comedy drama that proves to be a moving little tale thanks mainly to its savvy casting. However, it is Hollywood's best kept secret, Hoffman, producing another amazing turn, here giving us both raw and touching in one brilliant swoop. The story is predictable and Schumacher doesn't bother with the word 'original', nevertheless he succeeds in creating a bizarre but heartfelt film, and the most off beat crowd pleaser you'll probably see this year.

Rotten Tomatoes Score:



Drama, Comedy


Joel Schumacher


Joel Schumacher


Phillip Seymour Hoffman, Robert De Niro, Barry Miller, Chris Baur


Bruce Roberts


112 minutes








These pages copyright Union Films, 2001-2023. All views expressed in these pages are those of Union Films, and are not necessarily those of the University Of Southampton, or the Students' Union. All logos and trademarks are property of their respective organisations.